Web DesignComplete guide
How to choose a web design company (12 questions to ask)
Twelve questions to ask a web design company, each with the answer you want and the answer to walk away from, plus one sourced cost section.

Choose a web design company by the answers it gives to twelve questions about ownership, process, and money, not by how good its portfolio looks. Anyone can show you attractive screenshots. Far fewer will tell you in writing who will own your domain, what happens to your Google rankings on launch day, and what the first twelve months will cost in total.
I have been building websites in Minnesota since 2012, and most of the rescue jobs that reach me are not design problems. They are ownership problems, handoff problems, and “the person who built it stopped answering email” problems. A school office that cannot update its own lunch menu. A home care agency that discovers its domain is registered to a former contractor. A nonprofit that relaunches and loses every inbound link to its donation page because nobody wrote a redirect map.
None of that is visible in a portfolio. All of it is visible in the answers below. Each question comes with the answer you want and the answer that should end the conversation.
This article is about choosing a company. If you are weighing one freelancer and want the contract-level questions, read 15 questions to ask before you hire a web designer instead. If you are not sure you should hire anyone, start with build it yourself or hire someone.
What goes wrong when you pick the wrong web design company?
Bad websites are rarely the problem. Stranded websites are.
The four failures I see repeatedly: you cannot edit your own content, so the site goes stale within a year. You cannot leave, because the platform is proprietary or the accounts are in the company’s name. You lost search traffic at launch and nobody noticed for a quarter. Or the total cost turned out to be far above the quote once hosting, content, photography, and a mandatory care plan were added.
Every one of those is preventable with a question asked before you sign.
The 12 questions to ask before you hire
Ask these on a call, then ask for the important answers in the proposal. A company that answers well out loud and vaguely in writing has told you something.
1. Who owns the domain, hosting, code, and design files when we are done?
The answer you want: you do, all four, in accounts registered under your organization’s name and email. The domain sits in a registrar account you control. The hosting is in your name, on your card. You receive the site files and the layered design source files, not just flattened images.
Walk away if you hear: “We handle all of that for you, so you never have to think about it.” That is convenience talking, and it becomes a hostage situation the day you want to leave. If you are not sure what you hold today, how to check whether you own your website walks through the accounts one at a time.
2. Can I edit the site myself, and what exactly can I edit?
The answer you want: a specific list (pages, staff bios, events, posts, hours, PDFs), a recorded training session, and written documentation you keep. The right setup gives non-technical staff safe control over the content that changes often and locks the structure that should not change.
Walk away if you hear: either extreme. “You can edit everything” often means a page builder with forty settings per block, where one wrong click breaks the layout. “Just email us for changes” means every typo is a support ticket and a fee.
3. What happens to my Google rankings when this launches?
The answer you want: specifics. We keep your existing URLs where we can, we 301-redirect the ones that change, we preserve page titles and headings on pages that already rank, and we compare Search Console data 30 and 90 days after launch.
Walk away if you hear: “SEO is a separate service,” or “rankings always dip after a redesign, that’s normal.” Rankings can wobble for a couple of weeks. A permanent collapse is a botched migration, and the mechanics are in moving your website to a new platform without losing rankings.
4. Is there a redirect map, and can I see it before launch?
This is question three with teeth. A redirect map is a spreadsheet with every old URL in one column and its new destination in the other.
The answer you want: yes, it exists before launch day, and here it is.
Walk away if you hear: a pause while they work out what you mean. If a company does not know the term, it has not done a migration before, and you should only hire it for a brand-new site.
5. Who writes the content?
The answer you want: a plain sentence in the proposal. “Client provides copy for all pages,” or “we write copy for eight pages based on interviews.” There is no wrong answer, only a wrong assumption.
Walk away if you hear: nothing. Content is where most projects stall. I have watched a build that was ready in a month sit for several more because nobody at the organization had time to write staff bios. If your team will not produce copy, put paid copywriting in the scope up front rather than discovering the gap in week three.
6. What is not included?
Ask it exactly that way.
The answer you want: a list, given without flinching. Stock photography, photo shoots, logo design, copywriting, translations, ongoing SEO, third-party software licenses, email hosting, and post-launch changes beyond a stated revision window.
Walk away if you hear: “Everything is included.” The company has either not read your project or is planning to define “everything” narrowly later.
7. What is my total cost in the first 12 months?
Not the build price. The build price plus hosting, plus the domain renewal, plus any care plan, plus any license fees, plus the changes you will realistically ask for.
This is the one place in this article where I will quote numbers, and every one of them is someone else’s. TayoPro does not publish a rate card; each project is a fixed price against a written scope. These are the market figures I would use to judge any quote, mine included.
| What you are pricing | Published figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| A small-business website, broadest range | $1,000 to $15,000 | GoodFirms survey of 100+ web development companies, cited by WebFX, 2026 |
| Where most projects land | Under $10,000 | Clutch 2026 web design pricing data |
| Where most small businesses actually spend | $1,500 to $5,000 | The Lonely Entrepreneur, 2026 |
| A five-page business site | Freelancer $2,500 to $5,000; agency $5,000 to $12,000 | 2026 cost guides |
| A 10 to 20 page site from a larger agency | $15,000 to $40,000 | Clique Studios redesign FAQ |
| Agency hourly rate | $100 to $149 | Clutch 2026 |
| Agency and freelancer hourly, wider spread | Agency $80 to $250; freelancer $40 to $150 | ProjectCostEstimator, 600+ quotes, 2026 |
| Managed WordPress hosting, one site | $18 to $50 a month | SiteGround, Pressable, Flywheel, WP Engine, and Kinsta pricing pages, read October 2026 |
| Care plan, Twin Cities agencies that publish prices | $50 to $100 a month with no content time; $149 to $250 with 30 to 60 minutes of edits; $749 to $850 for four to five hours | Six Twin Cities agency pricing pages, read October 2026 |
| Ongoing costs, national benchmark | $10 to $200 a month | WebFX 2026 |
Two things to do with that table. First, place the quote you have in front of you. A number well above the Clique Studios band for a ten-page site needs a written explanation of what is different; a number well below the Lonely Entrepreneur band usually means a template with your logo dropped in. Second, do the year-one arithmetic yourself: the build, plus twelve months of hosting, plus twelve months of whatever care plan is attached. A care plan at the top of the Twin Cities bands costs more than many builds within two years, which is fine if it is doing two hours of real work every month and a bad deal if it is automated plugin updates. Ask what the plan includes, in hours and tasks. How much website maintenance costs has the full comparison.
Walk away if you hear: a build price and a shrug about everything else.
8. Who will I actually talk to during the project?
The answer you want: a name, and that person is in the meeting where you ask.
Walk away if you hear: “our team” repeated four times without a name. At a large agency, the person who pitched you is frequently not the person who builds your site, and sometimes not the person who answers your email afterward. That is not automatically bad, but you should know it going in. At a small studio the answer should be simple. On our projects it is me, and you can see who I am and how I work before you commit to anything.
9. What is your process when we disagree about the design?
The answer you want: something structural. We present two directions, you pick one, we do two rounds of revisions inside the scope, and further rounds are billed at a stated rate.
Walk away if you hear: “We just keep going until you’re happy.” That sounds generous and it is how projects die. Unlimited revisions with no decision process means the loudest board member gets the site, the timeline triples, and both sides end up resentful.
10. What happens if we stop working together?
The answer you want: something boring. You keep everything, we transfer the accounts within a stated number of business days, and there is no fee to leave. Ask specifically about termination fees, minimum terms, and whether the site keeps working if the care plan lapses. On a normal build, the site keeps serving pages with no updates; you simply stop getting patches and support.
Walk away if you hear: a 24 or 36 month minimum term, a platform you cannot export from, or a site that stops working when the monthly payment does. All three mean the monthly fee, not the website, is the product.
11. Can I see three sites you built three or more years ago that are still live?
This is my favorite question and almost nobody asks it. A portfolio shows launch-day screenshots. Three-year-old live sites show whether the work survived contact with a real organization.
The answer you want: three URLs. Click through them. Is the content current or frozen? Does the site still load fast? Did the organization keep it, or quietly move to something else? Then email one of those clients directly, not a reference the company hand-picked. Our project archive lists client sites you can open and judge for yourself.
Walk away if you hear: only work from the last year, or a portfolio of links that are dead because the clients left.
12. Do you build accessibly, and how do you check?
The answer you want: a standard and a method. WCAG 2.1 Level AA, keyboard navigation tested by a person, color contrast checked, real alt text, headings in order, forms with labels.
Walk away if you hear: “We’ll add an accessibility widget.” Overlay widgets do not fix the underlying markup.
This is a legal question for some of you. The Justice Department’s ADA Title II web rule sets WCAG 2.1 Level AA for state and local government entities, which includes public school districts and Minnesota charter schools, with compliance dates of April 26, 2027 for entities serving 50,000 or more people and April 26, 2028 for smaller entities and special districts, following the April 2026 interim final rule. It is a practical question for everyone else: WebAIM’s 2026 scan of the top one million home pages found detectable WCAG 2 failures on 95.9 percent of them, averaging 56.1 errors per page. If you serve seniors, people with disabilities, or families navigating services, an inaccessible site turns away exactly the people you exist for. The website accessibility guide for small organizations covers what to fix first.
Freelancer, small studio, or large agency?
There is no universally right answer. There is a right answer for your project size, your internal capacity, and your tolerance for risk.
| Freelancer | Small studio | Large agency | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who you talk to | The person doing the work | The person doing the work | An account manager |
| Speed on small changes | Fastest | Fast | Slowest |
| Risk if one person gets sick or quits | High, single point of failure | Moderate | Low |
| Strategy and content help | Varies widely | Usually included | Deep, and priced accordingly |
| Multi-stakeholder review | Rarely built for it | Usually | Built for it |
| Procurement, RFPs, insurance certificates | Often cannot | Usually can | Always can |
| Support in year three | A coin flip | Reasonable odds | Contractual |
| Published hourly rates | $40 to $150 (ProjectCostEstimator 2026) | $100 to $149 (Clutch 2026) | $80 to $250 (ProjectCostEstimator 2026) |
| Best fit | One clear project, decisive client | Small business, nonprofit, school, clinic | Enterprise, multi-brand, national campaigns |
Freelancers get unfairly maligned by agencies, mine included. A good freelance designer with five years of steady clients will do excellent work on a well-defined project, often faster and for less. The real risk is continuity, not skill: one person takes a full-time job, moves, or has a baby, and your site has no maintainer. Mitigate it by owning every account yourself and using a mainstream platform anyone can pick up. The questions that matter most in that case are in 15 questions to ask before you hire a web designer.
Large agencies earn their price when you have eight stakeholders, a legal review, a brand system to enforce, and a budget that makes a dedicated project manager rational. If your project is a twelve-page site for a Twin Cities nonprofit, an agency built for national retail clients will assign you its most junior team and still charge agency rates. The regional landscape, by specialty, is in top web design agencies in Minnesota and the best web design companies in Minneapolis.
How do I check references without wasting everyone’s time?
Ask the company for three clients. Then find two more yourself from its portfolio that it did not offer, and email the ones you found.
Ask those clients four things. Did it launch on the promised date, and if not, why? What did the final invoice total compared to the quote? How long does it take to get a response now that the project is over? Would you hire them again for the next project?
The fourth question does most of the work. People are polite in writing until you ask them to commit to doing it again.
How should I run the decision?
Get three proposals. Not one, and not eight.
Score each on ownership, clarity of scope, total first-year cost, who you will actually talk to, and evidence of work that lasted. Put price fourth or fifth, not first. The gap between two quotes for the same page count is almost always the strategy and content work, and that is the part that determines whether the site produces anything.
If you are a nonprofit running a formal process, the nonprofit website RFP template turns these questions into a document you can send out. If you want to understand the market before you talk to anyone, read how much a website costs in Minnesota, which carries the full set of sourced benchmarks, and how long a website takes to build so a timeline promise means something to you.
Where TayoPro fits, and where it does not
We are a small studio in Edina, Minnesota. Since 2012 I have designed and built more than 220 websites, mostly for nonprofits, schools, mosques, home care and therapy providers, and small businesses across the Twin Cities and greater Minnesota. You will get the twelve answers above in writing before you sign anything, and the price is fixed against a written scope.
We are the wrong choice in a few cases, and I would rather say so here than in a proposal you have to decline. If you need a district-wide platform with student information system integration and multi-school content governance, hire an education-platform vendor. If you are a national brand that needs hundreds of pages, several languages, and a round-the-clock service agreement, hire a bigger firm. If your site is fine and your problem is that nobody can find you, buy local search work or fix your Google Business Profile before you buy a redesign.
What to do next
Send the twelve questions to every company you are considering on the same day, and compare the written replies side by side. Then open three of each company’s old sites and email one of those clients.
If you want a second pair of eyes on a proposal you have already received, tell us what you are working on. TayoPro designs and builds websites and keeps them maintained month to month, both at a fixed price quoted in writing, and we will tell you plainly if you do not need either one, or if the proposal in your hand is better than the one I would write.
FAQ
Questions people ask about this
What questions should I ask a web design company before hiring?
Ask who owns the domain, hosting, code, and design files at the end; what you can edit yourself; what happens to your Google rankings at launch and whether a redirect map exists; who writes the content; what is excluded from the price; the total first-year cost; who your day-to-day contact is; how disagreements and departures are handled; what accessibility standard they build to; and to see three sites they built three or more years ago that are still live.
How much should a small business website cost?
The widest reputable range is GoodFirms' survey of 100+ web development companies, cited by WebFX in 2026, at $1,000 to $15,000. Clutch's 2026 pricing data says most web design projects on its platform come in under $10,000, and 2026 cost guides put a five-page business site at $2,500 to $5,000 from a freelancer and $5,000 to $12,000 from an agency. TayoPro does not publish prices; every project is a fixed price against a written scope.
Is it a red flag if a web design company will not give a price?
Refusing to give a fixed number before a scoping conversation is normal, because nobody can price a site without a page list. Refusing to talk about money at all until a contract is on the table is the red flag, because it usually means the price is discovered later, upward. A reasonable company will walk you through how it prices and commit to a written number once the scope is agreed.
Should I hire a freelancer, a small studio, or a large agency?
Hire a freelancer for a small, well-defined project when you can tolerate one person's schedule. Hire a small studio when you need design, development, content structure, and post-launch support coordinated by people who will still be reachable in two years. Hire a large agency when you have many stakeholders, a procurement process, and a budget the agency's project-management overhead makes rational.
What happens to my website if I stop paying my web design company?
It depends on where the accounts live. If you own the domain, hosting, and files, you can move to another provider with no leverage against you. If the company holds any of those, ending the relationship can mean losing the site or paying to get it back. Ask this before signing and get the answer written into the contract.
Do schools and nonprofits need an accessible website?
Public school districts and public charter schools are covered by the Justice Department's ADA Title II web rule, which sets WCAG 2.1 Level AA as the standard, with compliance dates of April 26, 2027 for public entities of 50,000 or more people and April 26, 2028 for smaller entities and special districts. Nonprofits and private businesses face a less settled legal picture and a very real practical one: an inaccessible site turns away the donors, families, and clients you exist to serve.
Keep reading
Comparisons13 min read
Hiring someone to update your website: your real options
Hosting plan, national vendor, freelancer, or local care plan: what each costs to update your website in 2026, and the questions to ask first.
Web Design13 min read
15 questions to ask before you hire a web designer
The pre-signing conversation with a freelance web designer: contract terms, ownership, hosting, handoff, and what happens if they disappear.
Website Costs17 min readComplete guide
How much does a website cost in Minnesota?
A GoodFirms survey puts small-business websites at $1,000 to $15,000 and Clutch says most projects land under $10,000. Here is what moves the number.


